Are you looking to replace gas furnace with electric one? You are not alone; many people opt for this way out after repeatedly doing gas furnace repair Santa Clarita on their old systems.

At HVAC Santa Clarita, we understand that this decision is a crucial one that can significantly impact your home comfort and energy bills. In this guide, we’ll explore when it’s best to replace your natural gas furnace with an electric system and when it might not be the ideal choice. We’ll also look at how our professional services, including gas furnace repair, maintenance, and furnace installation Santa Clarita, can assist you in making this transition seamlessly.

Ready? Let’s go.

Electric Vs Gas Furnace: Making the Right Choice for Your Home

When it comes to choosing a heating system for your home, both gas and electric furnaces are popular options.

These two types of heating systems work using the same principle: They heat air directly and distribute it through ducts to keep your home warm. The real dilemma comes in choosing which suits your home and lifestyle best. Let’s dive right into the similarities and differences between these two choices.

Cost Considerations

Gas furnaces usually come with a higher upfront cost for both purchase and installation, whereas electric furnaces tend to be more budget-friendly. On average, installing a new gas furnace in a 2,000 square-foot home can range from $4,500 to $6,000, while an electric furnace typically costs between $2,000 and $4,000.

It’s important to note that while electricity costs more than natural gas in many areas, gas furnaces offer long-term energy savings due to their increased efficiency. Therefore, individuals with gas furnaces can anticipate lower energy costs over time.

It is, however, essential to consider the long-term implications beyond the upfront installation cost. The choice between the two might depend on the size of your home and your climate. In smaller, warmer homes, an affordable electric furnace can make sense, as it won’t be in constant use.

Installation Complexity

Gas furnaces are generally larger and complex systems, but they are much easier and less expensive to install. If you lack experience in installing such equipment, it’s advisable to hire a certified heating and cooling contractor for a seamless installation.

Lifespan and Maintenance

Electric furnaces often have a longer lifespan, lasting 20 years or more, while gas furnaces typically last from 15 to 20 years. Both types require annual maintenance to operate efficiently. Regular tune-ups help clean the internal components and identify potential issues, preventing significant repairs.

Safety and Efficiency

Gas furnaces burn fuel and produce carbon dioxide, which can be dangerous if there’s a leak. The most common cause of carbon (II) oxide leaks is a crack in the heat exchanger. Regular maintenance is crucial to minimize the risk of such leaks.

Electric furnaces are generally considered safer due to their combustion-free operation.

In terms of energy efficiency, gas furnaces are known to heat spaces more efficiently and quickly than electric ones. Electric furnaces use coils as their heat source, which can take longer to warm up spaces, especially in cold climates. They are also more susceptible to wear and tear in colder regions.

For those seeking higher energy efficiency, it’s advisable to consult experts like HVAC Santa Clarita for energy-efficient furnace models tailored to your needs.

Noise Levels

Noise levels can be an important factor when deciding between gas and electric furnaces. Gas furnaces tend to produce more noise due to the combustion process and the operation of the blower motor. This noise can be concerning to those who value a quieter living environment.

In contrast, electric furnaces generally operate more quietly since they do not involve combustion. The absence of burning fuel results in a softer and less disruptive heating process. For individuals who value a peaceful, noise-free atmosphere in their homes, electric furnaces can provide a more tranquil heating experience.

Power Backup

Backup systems are essential considerations when choosing between an electric or gas furnace. Electric furnaces are entirely reliant on electricity, meaning they won’t function in case of power outages unless equipped with a backup generator.

Gas furnaces, on the other hand, often have the advantage of working independently of electricity. This reliability can be crucial for people in areas prone to power interruptions, ensuring uninterrupted heating during adverse weather or emergencies.

If you experience extreme weather that causes power outages, it is safer to stick with a gas heating system.

Resale Value

The type of heating system in a home can significantly impact its resale value. Gas furnaces, with their higher upfront costs, tend to contribute to higher resale values.

This is because they offer energy efficiency and lower operational costs, which can attract prospective buyers. The potential for lower utility bills with a gas furnace can make the property more appealing, making it a wise investment for people looking to sell their homes.

If you’re planning to sell your house in a few years, the best choice you can make is to stick with a gas furnace.

Indoor Air Quality and Health

Deciding whether to use a gas or electric furnace is super important for the air you breathe inside your house.

Gas furnaces can release carbon monoxide, which can be harmful if not handled properly. You need to take good care of them to stay safe. On the other hand, electric furnaces don’t release such toxic substances, making it safer for your house.

Individuals concerned about air quality or health should consider an electric furnace. However, if you opt for a gas furnace, ensure you have good airflow and maintain it to keep the air healthy inside.

Maintenance Upkeep

When comparing maintenance requirements between electric and gas furnaces, you will realize that electric furnaces generally demand less upkeep. Since electric furnaces don’t involve the combustion of fossil fuels, there’s less need for cleaning and maintenance than gas furnaces. Gas furnaces, on the other hand, need regular cleaning to prevent the buildup of soot and debris.

Furthermore, the risk of carbon dioxide poisoning and gas leaks, which can be life-threatening (1), is eliminated with electric furnaces, making them a safer option for homeowners and reducing the need for extensive safety-related maintenance.

Gas vs Electric Furnace: When to Consider Replacing Your Gas Furnace with an Electric Furnace

When is the best time to replace your gas furnace with an electric one? If you have been considering these options, it is best to ensure your situation aligns well with the following pros of choosing electric furnaces over natural gas furnaces.

Energy Efficiency

In general, gas furnaces are considered more energy-efficient compared to electric furnaces. Gas furnaces use natural gas as a fuel source, and they can heat a home more quickly and efficiently than electric furnaces, which typically use electric resistance heating elements. The higher energy efficiency of gas furnaces means they can heat the same amount of space while using less energy.

However, it’s essential to note that overall energy efficiency can vary based on factors such as the furnace’s age, design, and maintenance. To make the most energy-efficient choice, consider newer, high-efficiency models and regular maintenance for both types of furnaces.

At HVAC Santa Clarita, we specialize in the installation of electric furnaces. Our team of HVAC experts can help you select and install a heating system that best suits your home’s needs, ensuring maximum energy efficiency.

Environmental Concerns

If you’re concerned about the environmental impact of burning natural gas, electric heating can be a cleaner, more eco-friendly option. Electric furnaces produce no greenhouse gas emissions during operation, making them a greener choice.

We can help you make a seamless transition from a gas furnace to an electric one. Our skilled technicians will ensure your new electric system is installed precisely and efficiently.

Instances When It Is Best To Stick With Your Natural Gas Furnace

Before switching, think twice about whether it would be worth your investment. There are several instances when sticking with a gas furnace serves you better than installing an electric heat system.

Some of the instances include:

Existing Infrastructure

If your home already has a gas furnace and the associated infrastructure, such as gas lines and ventilation, converting to an electric system might be costly and complicated.

If you need more clarification about the feasibility of conversion, our HVAC experts can inspect your current setup and guide you through the potential challenges and costs.

In such an instance, it is way better to transition to an electric heat pump system if you do not have an air conditioner. Heat pumps offer versatility, as they combine heating and cooling systems in one, which can help you save significantly in the long run.

Feel free to reach out to us for heat pump services Santa Clarita today. 

Climate Considerations

In regions with frigid winters, gas furnaces are often favored for generating high heat output. Electric furnaces might be less efficient in such climates.

Besides, gas furnaces are known to heat up the home very quickly compared to their electric furnace counterparts. If you are still undecided about making the gas-to-electric transition, start by considering your climate and how quickly you want your house to warm up.

If you’re still undecided, our team can help you explore heating options best suited to the Santa Clarita climate and your specific requirements.

HVAC Santa Clarita Has Got You Covered

Deciding to change or upgrade your gas furnace to an electric heating system can be a challenging decision. As you have already seen, there are many things you have to look at.

Replacing a new electric furnace with a comparable gas furnace will not be a straightforward task. This is why it is advisable to have professionals come to the site, check your house infrastructure, and help you decide the most efficient heating system for your household.

If you are stuck in such a dilemma, call us. Whether you are looking to shift to an energy-efficient heat pump, looking to get a better dive into heating costs, or looking for general Santa Clarita heating services, we have got you covered.

We offer all the heating services you require, including installation, repair, and maintenance of various heating systems.

Replace Gas Furnace With Electric: FAQs

Are you still stuck in the electric furnace vs gas furnace dilemma? These frequently asked questions can help you make the needed decision. 

Should I replace my Natural gas furnace with an electric furnace?

Whether to replace your gas furnace with an electric one depends on factors like your home’s size, climate, and energy efficiency goals. It’s advisable to consult with HVAC experts for a personalized recommendation. To get an expert opinion, search for “AC technician near me” and reach out with your questions. If you are in Santa Clarita or the surrounding area, please give us a call for free quotations and a consultation. 

Can I convert a gas furnace to an electric one?

Converting a gas furnace to an electric one is a complex process and not always feasible. It often involves extensive modifications, so it’s crucial to consult with HVAC professionals to assess the possibility and cost-effectiveness of such a conversion.

Which is better, a gas or electric furnace?

Choosing between a gas and electric furnace depends on your specific needs and circumstances. Gas furnaces are more energy-efficient and heat spaces quickly, while electric furnaces are safer and have lower upfront costs. It’s vital to keenly weigh the pros and cons to determine which is better for your situation.

Can I replace my gas furnace with an electric heat pump?

Yes, it is possible, but it requires careful consideration and planning. Heat pumps offer both heating and cooling and are energy efficient. Consult with HVAC professionals to assess the suitability of this switch for your home’s heating and cooling needs.

Can I replace my gas furnace with an electric heat pump?

Yes, it’s possible to replace a gas furnace with an electric heat pump. Heat pumps offer both cooling and heating functions and can be more energy-efficient. However, the feasibility and cost-effectiveness of such a replacement depend on factors like your climate, home size, and existing facilities. Consult HVAC professionals for a thorough evaluation.

Which is better, a heat pump or an electric furnace?

The choice between a heat pump and an electric furnace depends on your specific needs. Heat pumps are versatile, providing both heating and cooling, making them a more efficient choice in moderate climates. Electric furnaces are simpler and cost less upfront, but they’re less energy-efficient and only provide heating. The “better” option depends on your priorities and climate.

Is it cheaper to run an electric heat pump or a gas furnace?

The cost of operating and maintaining an electric heat pump versus a gas furnace varies depending on factors like local energy prices, the efficiency of the units, and the climate. Generally, gas furnaces have lower operational costs in areas with lower natural gas prices. At the same time, electric heat pumps are more cost-effective in regions with milder climates and higher electricity prices. An HVAC expert can provide a cost analysis tailored to your specific circumstances.

Final Thoughts On Replacing Gas Furnace With Electric

 There we go for the gas or electric furnace dilemma. Choosing between a gas furnace and an electric furnace ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and local conditions. Gas furnaces excel in extreme cold, offering fast and efficient heating. Electric heat pumps are versatile, providing heating and cooling, ideal for milder climate conditions. The decision should consider upfront costs, energy efficiency, safety, and environmental impact. To make the best choice, consult with HVAC professionals who can assess your unique situation, ensuring you enjoy optimal comfort, savings, and peace of mind in your home. HVAC Santa Clarita is ready to serve you for AC repair Santa Clarita, furnace and heat pump installation, replacement, and maintenance service, all to help you keep a comfortable home all year round. 

References

https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwizw77a3qOCAxWDgP0HHYWIBYs4FBAWegQIAxAB&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.cbc.ca%2Fnews%2Fscience%2Fgreener-heating-1.5429709&usg=AOvVaw2vQSjLuCqlBUilnWaSpmHZ&opi=89978449